The 50% Rule

A widely accepted guideline: if the repair costs more than 50% of a new appliance AND the unit is past half its expected lifespan, replacement is usually smarter. Below that, repair is almost always the winner.

Average Appliance Lifespans

Refrigerator: 13 years. Washer: 10 years. Dryer: 13 years. Dishwasher: 9 years. Oven / Range: 15 years. Cooktop: 14 years. Freezer: 11 years. Wine Cooler: 8 years. Premium brands (Sub-Zero, Miele, Wolf) often last 20+ years.

When Repair Is Almost Always Right

Simple mechanical failures (belts, gaskets, elements, valves) on modern appliances are almost always worth repairing. These parts cost $50–$200 and take under an hour to install.

When to Consider Replacement

Sealed-system refrigerator failures on units over 10 years old. Multiple simultaneous failures. Persistent problems after 2+ repairs. Efficiency upgrades (older appliances use 2–3x more energy).

Hidden Cost of Replacement

A new appliance is only part of the story: delivery ($100–$200), installation ($150–$500), disposal ($40–$100), and sales tax. A $1,200 fridge often costs $1,600 all-in — compared to a $280 repair that gives you 3–5 more years.

Get an Honest Quote First

Every Appliance Marketplace repair starts with a flat Free diagnostic — waived when you approve the repair quote. Our technicians tell you upfront if a repair does not make financial sense.